Introduction

Should your SaaS company create a new market or stand out in an existing one? This article breaks down the key tradeoffs.

What’s the Problem It Solves?

Many B2B SaaS companies believe they have no real competitors and rush to invent new categories. Others blend into crowded markets by adding more features. The problem is knowing when to create something entirely new and when to simply be better than what exists.

Quick Summary

Category creation means building a new space in the market-solving a problem in a way no one has before. Think of how HubSpot created “inbound marketing” or how Uber redefined transportation. It’s bold and can make you the leader, but it demands time, money, and market education. You must teach people not only why your product is valuable but why your entire idea should exist.

Differentiation, on the other hand, is about standing out inside an existing category. You build on what people already know, improving features, experience, or service. This is less risky, faster to launch, and easier to explain to customers, but it’s also harder to maintain a clear identity when everyone’s doing the same thing.

The article explains two ways SaaS companies differentiate: horizontal (broad, across industries) and vertical (focused on one niche). Both can work, but the choice depends on customer type and concentration. The core lesson is that neither path is “better”-each fits different goals, resources, and markets.

If your market has unmet needs and you can define a new problem and teach people to care, category creation makes sense. But if demand already exists and you can outdo current players, differentiation is usually smarter.

Key Takeaways

• Category creation means defining a new problem and solution, not just being first.
• Differentiation builds on existing markets by offering a better or more specific solution.
• Horizontal SaaS covers many industries; vertical SaaS serves one niche deeply.
• Category creation needs long-term vision and heavy investment.
• Differentiation relies on clear customer understanding and faster execution.
• The right choice depends on market maturity, competition, resources, and readiness to educate.

What to Do

• Study your market deeply to see if demand already exists or if you can create it.
• Assess resources honestly-category creation is costly and time-intensive.
• If competing in an existing space, sharpen your value message and user experience.
• Build marketing that matches your choice: thought leadership for category creators, clarity and proof for differentiators.
• Keep improving your product and narrative-both paths demand constant evolution.

‍